top of page
The Rules Lawyer

How Does Point Buy Work in DnD 5e and One DnD?

Updated: Mar 11, 2023


A wizard in One DnD optimized to be super powerful, with purple lines of force pulsing from its eyes and spell book.

How to Use the Point Buy System to Generate Characters in DnD?


The point buy system is a method of character creation in Dungeons and Dragons (DnD) 5e and One DnD that allows players to allocate a set number of points to their character's ability scores. These ability scores represent the inherent abilities and aptitudes of a character, such as their strength, intelligence, and charisma.


To Use The Point Buy System


Players start with 27 points they can use to purchase ability scores for their character.

(This number can be increased or decreased by the dungeon master to adjust the strength of characters in their campaigns.)





Each Ability Score Has a Corresponding Point Cost, with Higher Scores Costing More Points

  • Starting with a stat of 8 costs nothing.

  • A stat of 9 costs 1 point

  • A stat of 10 costs 2 points

  • A stat of 11 costs 3 points

  • A stat of 12 costs 4 points

  • A stat of 13 costs 5 points

  • A stat of 14 costs 7 points

  • A stat of 15 costs 9 points

  • You can not purchase a stat above 15 using the point buy method.

DnD Point Buy 5e Pros

The point buy system allows players to customize their character's abilities to fit their desired play style and role within the party. It also helps to balance the power level of characters, as players must carefully consider how they want to allocate their points.

Cons

You sacrifice the chance that luck delivers a very powerful character. And you are locked into a 8 to 15 range for stats.


Overall, the point buy system is a flexible and customizable way to create a character in DnD 5e, and is a popular choice among players looking to create a well-rounded and balanced character.


Will The point buy system or rolling 4D6 and subtracting the lowest roll typically generate stronger characters?


The point buy system allows players to carefully consider and allocate their points in a way that fits their desired play style and character concept. This can result in a well-rounded and balanced character with a strong set of abilities. However, it may be more difficult to achieve extremely high ability scores using the point buy system, as the cost of higher scores increases significantly.


18 is considered very powerful in any one stat. The chance of rolling an 18 using 4 D6 and subtracting the lowest die roll is approximately 5.5%.


To calculate this, you can consider all of the possible combinations of rolls that would result in an 18 after subtracting the lowest roll. There are a total of 6^4 = 1296 possible combinations of rolls using 4 D6. Of these, there are only about 72 combinations that result in an 18 after subtracting the lowest roll.


So, the probability of rolling an 18 using 4 D6 and subtracting the lowest roll is 72/1296 = 5.5%. It is worth noting that this probability assumes that all rolls are equally likely, which may not always be the case depending on the specific dice being used. If you have dice that are biased to rolling high, you may end up with very strong characters using this method.


What is the average total you will get if you roll 4 six sided dice and subtract the lowest?


The average total you will get if you roll 4 six-sided dice (D6) and subtract the lowest roll is approximately 13.5.

To calculate this, you can consider all of the possible combinations of rolls using 4 D6 and compute the average total for each combination. There are a total of 6^4 = 1296 possible combinations of rolls using 4 D6.

The average total for each combination can be calculated by adding up the values of the dice and subtracting the lowest roll, then dividing by the number of dice. For example, the average total for the combination (1, 2, 3, 4) is (1 + 2 + 3 + 4 - 1)/4 = 5/4 = 1.25.

If you compute the average total for each of the 1296 combinations and take the average of all of these values, you will get an average total of approximately 13.5.

It is worth noting that this calculation assumes that all rolls are equally likely, which may not always be the case depending on the specific dice being used.

Rolling for ability scores allows players to potentially get very high or very low scores, which can result in characters with exceptional strength in certain areas but potentially weaker overall balance.


Ultimately, the strength of a character depends on a variety of factors, including the player's skill at optimizing their character's abilities and the party's overall strategy and composition.





Does the Point Buy System or Standard Array Generate a Higher Sum When You Add All Ability Scores Together?


In general, the standard array will yield a higher sum when you add all ability scores together compared to the point buy system.


The standard array is a pre-determined set of ability scores that players can use to create their character. The scores are: 15, 14, 13, 12, 10, 8. When these scores are added together, the total is 74.

On the other hand, the point buy system allows players to allocate a set number of points (usually 27) to their character's ability scores. Each ability score has a corresponding point cost, with higher scores costing more points. The total sum of the ability scores will depend on how the player allocates their points, but it is generally lower than the total sum of the standard array, as it is more expensive to increase ability scores using the point buy system.

It is worth noting that the strength of a character in D&D depends on a variety of factors, and the total sum of their ability scores is just one aspect to consider. The point buy system allows for more customization and allows players to allocate their points in a way that fits their desired play style and character concept.


What's the Best Method to Generate Powerful Characters?

Rolling 4D6 and subtracting the lowest.

It is generally more difficult to consistently generate characters with at least one 18 or higher stat using the point buy system or the standard array compared to rolling 4D6 and subtracting the lowest roll.


The point buy system allows players to allocate a set number of points to their character's ability scores, with higher scores costing more points. It is generally more expensive to increase an ability score and those scores are limited to 15, so it may be difficult to achieve very strong characters.

The standard array is a pre-determined set of ability scores (15, 14, 13, 12, 10, 8) that players can use to create their character. While it is possible to get an 18 or higher using the standard array, it is not guaranteed and will depend on the specific allocation of the scores.

Rolling 4D6 and subtracting the lowest roll allows players to potentially get very high scores, including an 18 or higher. However, it is also possible to get very low scores using this method, and the overall balance of the character's ability scores may be less consistent compared to the point buy system or the standard array.

Ultimately, it will depend on the specific preferences and goals of the player as to which method is best for generating characters with at least one 18 or higher stat in D&D 5e.


What's the Best Method to Consistently Generate Parties of Well-Rounded Characters?


The Standard Array.


The best stat generation method to create well-rounded characters and entire parties of well-rounded characters in D&D 5e may depend on the specific preferences and goals of the players.


One option is to use the point buy system, which allows players to allocate a set number of points to their character's ability scores. This allows players to customize their character's abilities to fit their desired playstyle and role within the party. It also helps to balance the power level of characters, as players must carefully consider how they want to allocate their points.


Another option is to use the standard array, which is a pre-determined set of ability scores (15, 14, 13, 12, 10, 8) that players can use to create their character. This can result in a well-rounded character with a strong set of abilities, as the scores are evenly distributed across all of the ability scores.

Ultimately, the best method for creating well-rounded characters and parties will depend on the specific preferences and goals of the players.


An Alternative Point Buy System for Creating Stronger Characters

In this alternative model, players can also choose to lower their ability scores in order to gain additional points. For example, if a player wanted to have a high charisma score, they might choose to lower their strength or constitution score below 8 in order to gain the extra points needed to purchase a high charisma score.


Additionally, in this model, characters can purchase ability score all the way up to 18.

Each ability score has a corresponding point cost, with higher scores costing more points.


  • You cannot reduce a stat below six

  • A stat of 6 gives you two points

  • A stat of 7 Gives you one point

  • Starting with a stat of 8 costs nothing.

  • A stat of 9 costs 1 point

  • A stat of 10 costs 2 points

  • A stat of 11 costs 3 points

  • A stat of 12 costs 4 points

  • A stat of 13 costs 5 points

  • A stat of 14 costs 7 points

  • A stat of 15 costs 9 points

  • A stat of 16 costs 11 points

  • A stat of 17 costs you 13 Points

  • A stat of 18 costs you 18 points

  • You can not buy stats above 18

What's your favorite character generation system? Leave your comments below.





483 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page